Local · Independent · Delicious

A slice of small-town magic.

Hand-tossed pizza, baked with local ingredients and a little mystery.

Explore the menu

Made fresh Pickup available Order online

House Pizzas

Our signature hand-tossed pies.

Specialty Pizzas

Big flavors from the Mystic kitchen.

Starters

Shareable favorites for the table.

Salads and Sandwiches

Fresh greens and oven-baked favorites.

Desserts and Drinks

A sweet finish and something cold to drink.

A slice of small-town magic.

House Pizzas

Mystic Special

Margherita

Pepperoni Classic

Garden Pie

White Clam

Meatball Ricotta

Four Cheese

Specialty Pizzas

Hot Honey Soppressata

Coastal Shrimp

Fig and Prosciutto

Buffalo Chicken

Truffle Mushroom

Chicken Pesto

Starters

Garlic Knots

Fried Mozzarella

Calamari

Meatball Skillet

Roasted Wings

Salads and Sandwiches

Mystic House Salad

Classic Caesar

Italian Chopped

Meatball Grinder

Chicken Parm Grinder

Desserts and Drinks

Tiramisu

Cannoli

Chocolate Cake

Italian Lemonade

Cold Brew

Fountain Soda